The family of Irish Coastguard volunteer Caitriona Lucas have asked that three former transport ministers, including Taoiseach Leo Varadkar, appear as witnesses at the full inquest into her death.

Ms Lucas (41), an Irish Coast Guard Doooin unit volunteer, died after a RIB attached to the Kilkee Coast Guard unit capsized during a search off the Clare coast on September 12th, 2016.

She was the first Irish Coast Guard volunteer to lose a life during a search operation.

At the opening of a preliminary inquest before Limerick city coroner John McNamara in Kilmallock court, Co Limerick yesterday, legal representatives for Ms Lucas’s family said that three former transport ministers had held responsibility for legislation which failed to establish an independent marine investigations body.

Maritime lawyer Michael Kingston asked Mr McNamara to call Mr Varadkar, along with Minister for Public Expenditure Paschal Donohoe, who served as transport minister from 2014, and Shane Ross, who took over the transport portfolio in May 2016, as witnesses.

Questions about the location of the lifejacket and helmet which Ms Lucas was wearing were also raised at the hearing.

Mr Kingston said that failure to set up an independent body for marine accident investigations had resulted in a European Court of Justice judgment being issued against Ireland in July 2020.

He said the State had failed to properly investigate an incident involving capsize of a rigid inflatable boat off Inch, Co Kerry in August 2014, which was similar in circumstances to the event which claimed Ms Lucas’s life off Kilkee.

This was criticised in the subsequent Marine Casualty Investigation Board report into Ms Lucas’s death, Mr Kingston noted.

A request by Mr Kingston to call board members of the MCIB was rejected by Mr McNamara, but he said that the MCIB report into Ms Lucas’s death would be admitted as evidence.

Mr Simon Mills, representing the Department of Transport which is responsible for the Irish Coast Guard, said that an inquest hearing “cannot be used as a collateral attack on the MCIB”.

Mr McNamara agreed that the Health and Safety Authority (HSA), including inspector Helen McCarthy who conducted a separate inquiry into Ms Lucas’s death, would be called.

Audio recordings of communication between the Kilkee Irish Coast Guard unit and the Irish Coast Guard Rescue 115 helicopter was also requested by Mr Kingston, along with drone footage taken by Ennis Civil.

Mr Kingston requested that independent experts be sought in relation to Ms Lucas’s lifejacket and helmet.

He also asked the coroner to establish the location of both pieces of equipment, which “had gone missing”.

HSA inspector Helen McCarthy told the coroner in response to a question about the lifejacket that Hugh Barry, who was a senior manager with the Irish Coast Guard at the time, “be questioned on that”.

Mr Kingston requested a number of other witnesses to be called and reports to be produced.

Mr McNamara proposed that these be set out in written depositions which he would consider.

This would require a second preliminary inquest hearing, which has been set for June 12th, he agreed. A date will then be set for a full hearing which may take two to three days, the coroner said, noting he would not "rush" the hearing.

Mr McNamara expressed his sincere condolences to the Lucas family.

A date has been set for an inquest hearing into the death of Irish Coast Guard volunteer Caitriona Lucas (41), over six years after her death off the Clare coast.

As The Irish Examiner reports, the Limerick coroner’s office has confirmed that the hearing will take place at Kilmallock courthouse, Co Limerick, on April 12th.

Ms Lucas, a mother-of-two, librarian and highly experienced volunteer with the Irish Coast Guard’s Doolin unit, died after a RIB attached to the Kilkee Coast Guard unit capsized during a search operation on September 12th, 2016.

She was the first Irish Coast Guard volunteer to lose their life during a tasking.

Ms Lucas’s husband, Bernard told journalist Gordon Deegan that it was “about time” that an inquest date had been set.

“I welcome it because by the time the inquest is held in April it will be six years and seven months,” Mr Lucas said, stating he did not know why there had been such a delay.

Maritime lawyer Michael Kingston had also recently described the delay in setting a date as “shocking”.

As Afloat has previously reported, two separate investigations were completed some time ago into the circumstances surrounding her death.

Maritime lawyer Michael Kingston

The Marine Casualty Investigation Board (MCIB) report was published in December 2018.

Two years ago, Ms Lucas’s husband, Bernard Lucas, was informed by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) that no criminal charges would be brought after a separate investigation by the Health and Safety Authority (HSA).

The MCIB report was critical of the Irish Coast Guard’s safety management system, and catalogued a number of systems and equipment failures in relation to the Kilkee Coast Guard unit.

However, Mr Lucas said that he “very disappointed” that the published MCIB report had failed to address questions over equipment his wife was wearing, and both he and members of the Kilkee Coast Guard unit queried the location given in the report.

Mr Kingston has also criticised the MCIB report into Ms Lucas’s death, and has called for a re-investigation.

Read more in The Irish Examiner here

Six years after Caitriona Lucas became the first Irish Coast Guard volunteer to die during active service, a documentary is due to be aired on Clare FM Radio today, September 12th, on her life.

“Caitriona was a hero...she should always be remembered,” programme director Padraic Flaherty has said of the hour-long documentary, which was made with the support of Ms Lucas’s family.

Ms Lucas (41), a librarian, mother of two, and advanced coxswain from Liscannor, Co Clare, had offered to help out the neighbouring Irish Coast Guard Kilkee unit in a search for a missing man on September 12th, 2016.

She hadn’t expected to go to sea, but the unit was short a crew member. She died after the Kilkee rigid inflatable boat (Rib) capsized in a shallow surf zone. Two other crew members survived.

Two years ago, the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) decided that no criminal charges should be brought in relation to the incident after a report was forwarded to it by the Health and Safety Authority (HSA).

The unpublished HSA report was one of two separate investigations. The second report by the Marine Casualty Investigation Board (MCIB) proved so contentious that it had to be published in two parts, and the responses to the draft were longer than the report itself.

Ms Lucas’s husband, Bernard, who was one of a number to raise questions about the MCIB report, told Clare FM that the new radio documentary was very emotional for him to hear.

However, he said it also recorded many positive memories of his late wife.

“There was a laugh in it... and good memories,” he told Clare FM last week.

Saying “no” to any request for help “wasn’t an option” for his late wife, Bernard noted, recalling her commitment to the Irish Coast Guard and Search and Rescue Dog Association.

He said he hoped people would realise how rewarding it is to give back to the community.

Padraic Flaherty said it was a great privilege to put the documentary together, and credited Bernard with providing him with contacts for family and friends.

Flaherty said he didn’t think anyone in the county and country would ever forget September 12th, 2016, when Ms Lucas lost her life.

“Caitriona was a hero...she should always be remembered,” Flaherty said.

“Catriona Lucas, Fearless” airs on Clare FM’s Morning Focus this Monday morning, September 12th from 11 am.

Listen to the preview of the documentary on Clare FM here

Clare Coast Guard volunteer Bernard Lucas left Ireland at the weekend for Tanzania on the 2022 Caitriona Lucas Challenge to climb Mount Kilimanjaro.

Dedicated to the memory of his late wife, Caitriona – the first Irish Coast Guard volunteer to die on active service – Lucas and team mates Cormac Coyne of Inis Oírr and Eoin Keane from Kilfenora aim to raise funds for the Burren Chernobyl Project.

The 5,895 meters (19,341 feet) peak is the highest mountain in Africa and the tallest freestanding mountain in the world.

Acclimatising to altitude will be one of the team’s greatest challenges, given the very individual impact on physiology of lower oxygen levels.

Bernard Lucas and colleagues Cormac Coyne, Micheál Healy and Eoin Keane on the summit of Kerry's Mount Brandon during final training for this year's Caitriona Lucas Challenge

Their final training run together involved participating in the Tom Crean Endurance Walk in Kerry last weekend.

Covid-19 had forced a pause to the annual challenge, which involved climbing 26 mountains across 32 counties in just 10 days in 2018 for charity.

Cormac Coyne, Pauliina Kauppila and Bernard Lucas on the Tom Crean Endurance Walk Photo: Cormac Coyne

The following year, 2019, Lucas and five colleagues – Cormac Coyne, Michael Healy, Pauliina Kauppila, Eoin Keane and Deirdre Linnane – travelled to Greenland for the Arctic Circle trail. An estimated average of 300 people annually tackle the 100-mile wilderness walk.

In an interview with Afloat’s Wavelengths podcast earlier this month, Lucas spoke about the Kilimanjaro climb preparations.

He also spoke about the situation with Doolin Coast Guard where he and nine other volunteers were dismissed, and about many unanswered questions relating to his wife’s death off the Clare coast on September 12th, 2016.

Several weeks ago, international maritime lawyer Michael Kingston questioned the delay in holding an inquest into the highly experienced Irish Coast Guard coxswain’s death.

Bernard Lucas on the Tom Crean Endurance Walk in Kerry (photo Cormac Coyne)

“It is shocking that almost six years after Ms Lucas’s death, no inquest has as yet been heard,” Mr Kingston told The Sunday Independent, pointing out that such a hearing would “properly investigate” what happened.

Mother-of-two Ms Lucas (41), an advanced coxswain with Doolin Coast Guard in Co Clare, had offered to help out the neighbouring Coast Guard unit from Kilkee in the search for a missing man.

She died after the Kilkee rigid inflatable boat (RIB) capsized in a shallow surf zone. Two other crew members on board the RIB, who were also thrown into the sea, survived.

Her husband and a number of Kilkee Coast Guard volunteers criticised aspects of the Marine Casualty Investigation Board report, which was published in two parts due to the extensive nature of submissions on the draft.

As Ms Lucas was pronounced dead in hospital in Limerick, responsibility for her inquest is with the Limerick coroner’s office.

The newspaper report said that the Limerick coroner’s office did not respond to several requests for comment 

You can listen back to Bernard Lucas’s interview here And more details on the Caitriona Lucas Challenge are here

On June 25th, Clare coast guard volunteer Bernard Lucas, along with Cormac Coyne of Inis Oir and Eoin Keane from Kilfenora will set out to climb 5,895 metres (19,341 feet) to the summit of Mount Kilimanjaro the highest mountain in Africa and the tallest freestanding mountain in the world.

The trio are making the ascent for the Caitriona Lucas Challenge, with funds going to the Burren Chernobyl Project. The challenge is named after Bernard’s late wife, Caitriona, who lost her life off the Clare coast on September 12th, 2016 - the first Irish Coast Guard volunteer to die while on a call-out.

Bernard spoke to Wavelengths this week about the climb, about the situation with Doolin Coast Guard where he and nine other volunteers were dismissed, and about many unanswered questions relating to Caitriona’s death.

Listen to Wavelengths below

Asked to respond to Bernard’s appeal for Minister of State for Transport Hildegarde Naughton to meet the Doolin Coast Guard unit, her department said that the Coast Guard is “currently fully engaged in the process of rebuilding the Doolin Unit, guided by the recommendations outlined in Kieran Mulvey’s report, issued on December 10th 2021.

“We can confirm that the selection of volunteers to provide service to the re-constituted unit on an interim basis as per the report recommendations was completed and those selected were informed,” it said.

Cormac Coyne (left) and Bernard Lucas, in training for the Caitriona Lucas Challenge to Mount Kilimanjaro in June 2022

“We can now confirm that management within the Coast Guard has commenced the process of recruitment to the Doolin Unit on a permanent basis. We can also confirm they have recently been in contact with all former volunteers in relation to this recruitment process,” the department said.

“The minister and the Coast Guard are fully engaged in this process and are very committed to ensuring Doolin Coast Guard Unit’s continued growth and renewal,” it continued.

“The minister meets with and engages with Coast Guard Unit volunteers on a regular basis and will also meet with Doolin Coast Guard Unit volunteers as part of this continuous engagement,” it said.

Details of the Caitriona Lucas Challenge to Mount Kilimanjaro are here

Caitriona and Bernard Lucas, Newfoundland, in October 2014

Irish Coast Guard volunteer Bernard Lucas has called for a re-investigation into the cause of his wife Caitriona’s death off the Clare coast in 2016.

In an interview with today’s Sunday Independent, Mr Lucas says he finds as “shocking” the criticisms of the Marine Casualty Investigation Board (MCIB) in a report commissioned by maritime lawyer Michael Kingston.

The report by Capt Neil Forde of Marine Hazard Ltd said the MCIB was “not fit for purpose”.

It was submitted by Mr Michael Kingston to several Oireachtas committees, including the Transport and Communications Network committee which sat on Friday last.

Ms Lucas (41), a librarian, mother of two, and advanced coxswain, had offered to help out the neighbouring Irish Coast Guard Kilkee unit in a search for a missing man on September 12th, 2016.

She hadn’t expected to go to sea, but the unit was short a crew member. She died after the Kilkee rigid inflatable boat (Rib) capsized in a shallow surf zone. Two other crew members survived.

Last summer, the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) decided that no criminal charges should be brought in relation to the incident after a report was forwarded to it by the Health and Safety Authority (HSA).

The unpublished HSA report was one of two separate investigations. The second report by the Marine Casualty Investigation Board (MCIB) proved so contentious that it had to be published in two parts, and the responses to the draft were longer than the report itself.

In a robust response, the Irish Coast Guard described the MCIB report as “flawed” and “misleading”, and argued that it was a “significant leap” to draw wider conclusions about safety standards based on one “tragic accident”.

In his submission to the draft report, Bernard Lucas queried why the investigation did not address failure to find personal locator beacons and other equipment issues, including the loss of helmets by three crew and the failure of lifejackets to inflate.

A postmortem identified a trauma to the side of Ms Lucas’s head at a point where it should have been protected by her helmet.

Last summer, the MCIB’s authority was questioned in a European Court of Justice judgment which found it is not independent as its board included the Department of Transport secretary-general, or his or her deputy, and the Marine Survey Office (MSO) chief surveyor. These two post holders have recently stood down.

The report commissioned by Mr Kingston claims the MCIB failed to investigate certain incidents which it has a statutory duty to inquire about, it questions its resources and independence.

It also says the MCIB inquiry into Caitriona Lucas’s death is “riddled with inaccuracies” – starting with the wrong location for the incident.

These inaccuracies were not corrected, even when highlighted in responses to the draft report, because MCIB investigators” simply have not had the resources required to do the job properly”, Mr Kingston told the Oireachtas Transport and Communications Networks committee hearing on Friday.

Capt Forde’s analysis also questions why the MCIB did not also investigate a previous incident which occurred in similar circumstances to that of Ms Lucas’s death, where an Irish Coast Guard Dingle unit RIB capsized in a surf zone off Inch, Co Kerry in August 2014.

The MCIB said in response that it does not comment on published reports issued on the conclusion of investigations, and said it was not the purpose of an investigation to attribute blame or fault – but to avoid other casualties occurring.

“Any person may report a marine accident to the MCIB directly and details are on the website,”it said in response to questions about its failure to follow up on the Dingle incident.

“All on-going investigations are noted on the website and members of the public may submit evidence about an investigation at any time should they so wish,” it said.

“The board may also re open investigations where it receives evidence to warrant that course of action,” it said, but it was “not in receipt of any requests to re-open any investigation, nor is it in receipt of any objections by any interested parties to the recommendations it has made”.

“The members of the MCIB recognise that some investigations arise from very tragic circumstances and that any investigation may cause added distress,” it said.

Read more on the Sunday Independent here

Following January’s film on Ireland’s offshore fishing industry, the latest episode of TG4 documentary series Tabú reaches into the heart and soul of the Irish Coast Guard — as told by the coastguard members in their own words.

In the aftermath of the loss of Rescue 116 and volunteer Caitríona Lucas, An Garda Cósta - Ár n-Insint Féin, which screens this coming Wednesday 4 March, explores how they continue to serve in spite of the tragedies.

Focusing on operations after the biggest tragedy that has happened to any Blue Light service in Ireland, the hour-long film reveals the anguish of the search, along with the coping mechanisms of “the coastguard family”.

And according to the producers, the documentary also reveals the dangers of the job and how they stay on the right side of risk.

Produced and directed by Darina Clancy for Midas Productions, Tabú: An Garda Cósta - Ár n-Insint Féin broadcasts Wednesday 4 March at 9.30pm on TG4.

#Coastguard - Two new postage stamps in tribute to the Irish Coast Guard are based on a painting by a volunteer who died in service, as the Sunday Independent reports.

The painting by Caitríona Lucas, who died during a rescue operation off Kilkee in September 2016, has been adapted into a tribute to both her and the crew of the coastguard helicopter Rescue 116 who were lost in March 2017.

Two stamps show separately a rendering of the Sikorsky S-92 helicopter, and an Irish Coast Guard rescue boat similar to what Caitríona had crewed.

The commemorative stamps were launched at the GPO last week by members of the coastguard and Caitríona’s widower Bernard.

In a joint statement, coastguard units in Skerries, Dun Laighaire and Greystones said their thoughts are with the families of Caitríona, Capt Dara Fitzpatrick, Capt Mark Duffy, winch operator Paul Ormsby and winchman Ciaran Smith.

“This gesture by An Post is heartwarming to us all,” they added.

#Coastguard - There was no evidence of effective management at Kilkee’s coastguard station when volunteer Caitríona Lucas died during a rescue operation almost two years ago, according to a draft report into the incident.

The Irish Times has details of the draft report from the Marine Casualty Investigation Board (MCIB), which adds that the RIB on which Lucas was travelling before it capsized on 12 September 2016 was being used outside of the Irish Coast Guard’s own operational limits.

Parallels were also drawn to a similar incident two years prior involving a coastguard RIB in a “surf zone” near Dingle, which prompted a series of recommendation that were not “fully implemented” by the Irish Coast Guard, according to the MCIB.

The Irish Times has much more on the story, while Lorna Siggins also writes on how Lucas’ death occurred amid a tumultuous time for the Co Clare coastguard unit.

#Coastguard - Next year’s commemorative stamp programme from An Post will feature a tribute to the four coastguard crew lost in the Rescue 116 tragedy one year ago.

RTÉ News reports that Caitriona Lucas, the coastguard volunteer who died during a rescue mission in September 2016, will be included as part of a series paying tribute to the work of the Irish Coast Guard.

Among other stamps due in 2019 will be one to mark 100 years since the first non-stop transatlantic flight from Newfoundland to Galway by British aviators Alcock and Brown.