There has been a disappointed reaction from a number of fishing vessel owners to terms offered under the Government's latest whitefish decommissioning scheme.
"We haven’t surveyed members yet as this is anecdotal, but we are hearing of dismay and disappointment,” Irish Fish Producers Organisation (IFPO) chief executive Aodh O’Donnell said.
“We are calling for immediate additional engagement by and clarification from Bord Iascaigh Mhara (BIM) on this,” O’Donnell said. “The disappointment is quite widespread among our members.”
Letters of offer to 57 owners have been issued by Bord Iascaigh Mhara (BIM). It says it will ensure that over 9,000 tonnes of quota fish valued at €35 million annually will be available for remaining whitefish vessels to catch, ensuring the remaining fleet's economic viability into the future.
Minister for Marine Charlie McConalogue has increased funding for the scheme from 60 million euro to 75 million euro– drawn from the EU Brexit Adjustment Reserve (BAR) which was allocated to mitigate the negative impact on the Irish fleet of Brexit.
Irish South and West Fish Producers’ Organisation (IS&WFPO) chief executive Patrick Murphy said that it was an “absolute scandal” that some applicants had received offers well below the market price of their vessels.
“This represents the latest in a series of victimisations of Irish fishermen – losing waters on EU access, losing quota due to Brexit, and now our government, which doesn’t have to spend a penny of exchequer money on this, trying to force people to accept derisory offers,” Murphy said.
Murphy said he had heard from several vessel owners who had been offered well below the lowest ceiling per gross tonne.
The decommissioning scheme, which was recommended by Ireland’s seafood task force in response to significant loss of access to quota due to Brexit, proposes paying applicants a basic payment of €3,600 per gross tonne(GT), and a “catch incentive premium” of up to €8,400 per GT for quota species covered under the TCA.
This would be calculated by indexing total vessel landings of quota stocks against the maximum total landings of quota stocks by any one vessel within each segment.
“When we were into the seafood task force, we did so in good faith, and when we saw terms and criteria for decommissioning, we said it was wrong as we felt it wasn’t going to be fit for purpose,”Murphy said.
“Now we see that not only are the criteria unworkable, but they are contradictory,” he said.
“For instance, penalising a vessel on its age when it might be more successful than a younger vessel,” he said.
“The increased funding by the minister is not enough, and it is ironic that crew will do better out of this in some cases than vessel owners,” Murphy said.
“It is immoral to roll out something like this when some people are unable to pay mortgages. One man was told that the decision to accept was not his, but the bank manager’s decision,” he said.
Approved applicants have until February 8th, 2023 to accept the offer. Once an offer is taken up, vessel owners must surrender their fishing licences within eight weeks and decommission their vessels, in an “environmentally compliant manner”, by October 31st,2023.