It’s time to ask serious questions about the EU’s attitude to Ireland and the Irish fishing industry, according to the Irish Fish Producers’ Organisation, which suspects that the European Union may be engaged in “closed doors” discussions with Iceland to give away more rights to fishing in Irish waters.
“There is a history of the EU Commission rushing through deals of this nature on before holiday periods to minimise opportunities for pushback and objections,” says the Chief Executive of the IFPO, Aodh O’Donnell. “We fear that this giveaway of more foreign access to Irish waters is being agreed behind closed doors. There is a lack of clarity, and Christmas is upon us, and we are very concerned.”
Iceland is seeking access to fish in Irish waters, in a new deal being negotiated with the EU. The country is not a member, but wants to catch valuable blue whiting in Irish waters. The species are no longer available in Iceland’s own extensive waters and Iceland has a record of arbitrarily increasing fishing quotas in its own waters, denuding stocks, according to industry critics.
“Bi-lateral negotiations are underway and may be near finalisation without our input or adequate consultation with Irish interests,” O’Donnell alleges. “We cannot let the EU off the hook. Ireland says to EU “No Icelandic Deal without Reciprocity. We will not stand idly by as EU negotiate a Norway type deal with Iceland while what it wants can destroy the Irish fishing industry.”
"we will not stand by and watch more plundering of our rich maritime resources by another non-EU country"
“The deal as it stands is nothing less than outrageous,” says Brendan Byrne of the Irish Fish Processors and Exporters Association (IFPEA). “Blue whiting is abundant and sustainably managed in Irish waters. However, allowing access to another non-EU country would be at the further expense of the livelihoods of Irish fishermen and the sustainability of the stock. We fear another sell-out. Iceland has a massive fishing fleet including factory ships that will covet our stock. There is no justice in allocating them rights to fish in our waters. The EU already threw Ireland under the bus when it came to the Brexit as we took the hardest hits. As a result of that disastrous transfer of Irish fishing quotas to the UK, Ireland has decommissioned 39 vessels and downsized our national fleet. Now, we find ourselves again in an unbelievable situation in granting a Third Country access whilst Ireland’s small fleet and onshore factories struggle with reduced fishing quotas.”
According to information, Iceland's fishing fish blue whiting in Irish waters would benefit that country to the value of €22.5 million, with no reciprocal benefit for Ireland.
“We aim to work in harmony with other EU Member States, but we will not stand by and watch more plundering of our rich maritime resources by another non-EU country,” says O Donnell.
“We fail to understand why our Minister and his officials are hastening an agenda driven by the EU Commission and to the benefit of an Iceland as a non-EU member. Why have we not learned lessons from the past?”
The industry organisations have called on Minister for the Marine Charlie MacConalogue, to immediately block any EU deal with Iceland.