Inishbofin residents have begun a petition seeking return of skulls taken by a British anthropologist from the island in 1890.
Anthropologist Alfred Cort Haddon enlisted Irish medical student Andrew Dixon to help him when he removed 13 skulls from the ruins of St Colman’s Monastery on the island.
Haddon informed the Royal Irish Academy that they were part of “a collection of Irish crania”, which he gave to Trinity College, Dublin’s (TCD) anthropological museum.
Inishbofin Heritage Museum director Marie Coyne learned of Haddon’s theft after a TCD-sponsored exhibition displayed photograph albums of Charles R Browne, who managed the university’s anthropological museum and was known as the “Irish head hunter”.
When Coyne initially raised the issue, TCD told RTÉ that it "no longer houses the collection” and “its current location” is “unknown".
However, as Ciarán Walsh of Maynooth University outlines in an article for RTÉ Brainstorm, he emailed Marie Coyne to inform her he had seen the skulls still "ranged out like blue jugs" in display cases in the ‘skull passage’– a storage area behind the theatre building in TCD.
He said they were clearly labelled "Inishbofin: Haddon & Dixon", and the collection included one skull from the Aran Islands and ten from St Finan’s Bay.
Walsh said that this triggered a five-year investigation of Victorian anthropology - the skull-measuring business - in Ireland in partnership with Maynooth University, TCD and the Irish Research Council.
Earlier this month,a TCD delegation told islanders at a meeting in the Inishbofin community centre that it was not empowered to take a decision on reburying the skulls – which had been taken illegally.
“They couldn’t tell us anything. I think they wanted to get the feeling on the ground,” Coyne said.
TCD said relevant state bodies would have to be consulted, and there will be a public consultation.
A petition initiated by Coyne and New York University anthropologist Pegi Vail says no further evidence is needed for the skulls and any material taken illegally to be returned to their community of origin. The petition says TCD is due to make a decision in mid-December on the issue.
Read more on RTÉ Brainstorm here
The petition is here