EU coastal states “haven’t taken the same hit” as Ireland in losing access to British fishing grounds and “must burden share”, an industry leader said.
The fishing industry is “not interested” in financial compensation, and wants to ensure it “gets fish back” if coastal communities are to survive, Killybegs Fishermen’s Organisation (KFO) chief executive Sean O’Donoghue has said.
Speaking on Newstalk Radio’s Pat Kenny Show today before appearing at an Oireachtas committee, Mr O’Donoghue said that if the total loss to nine coastal states is valued at 182 million euro, Ireland should have lost some 20 million euro in quotas.
Instead, Ireland’s loss has been calculated at over €42 million, he noted.
Dedicated junior fisheries minister
Also speaking on The Pat Kenny Show, Donegal priest Fr John Joe Duffy of Burtonport accused the Government of taking a “subservient” approach to Europe on the issue, and called for a dedicated junior fisheries minister.
Ireland’s overall quota loss has been valued in a post-Brexit economic analysis at 43 million euro, which is some 9 million euro more than originally estimated by Government ministers
After the Brexit deal was signed, Irish foreign affairs and marine ministers Simon Coveney and Charlie McConalogue had stated that the loss to Ireland of fishing quotas was €34 Million or 15% of €252 Million.
An economic analysis of fish quotas increases the Irish loss figure to €43 Million - but the landing figure for 2020 has been adjusted upwards to €288 Million to maintain the 15% cut total.
The Department of Agriculture, Food and Marine has not responded to queries about the figure change.
The recently published analysis calculates that the final quota reduction (after the transition period) for key stocks amounts to a 26% reduction in the western mackerel quota share, Ireland’s largest fishery
It calculates a 14 per cent reduction in Ireland’s largest non-pelagic fishery, Nephrops (prawns).
It says that the whitefish fisheries where there are notable reductions are: Hake (Celtic Sea) 3%, Haddock (Celtic Sea) 11%, Haddock (Irish Sea) 16%, Haddock (Rockall) 22.6%.
Other reductions are Megrim (Celtic Sea) 8%, Megrim (West of Scotland (19%), Anglerfish/Monkfish (Celtic Sea) 7%, Anglerfish/Monkfish (West of Scotland) 20%, and Pollack (Celtic Sea) 9%.
It calculates a 96 per cent reduction for herring (Irish Sea).
It also says that several smaller whitefish quotas in the Donegal/West of Scotland area have seen sizeable quota share reductions.
The reductions are graduated over the 5.5 year period of reciprocal access, but the largest part of the reduction, 60%, is between 2020 and 2021.
The analysis notes that the Brexit agreement contains a list of 105 stocks for which the UK has, or will receive, a Total Allowable Catch (TAC) share.
“ For 41 of these stocks, the UK’s share will remain unchanged from its current relative stability share. For eight stocks there is no transition period and the new UK quota shares, it is understood, apply from 2021,” it states.
“For the remaining stocks, 60% of the transition to the new shares occurs in 2021, followed by 70% in 2022, 80% in 2023 and 92% in 2024,” it says, and by 2025 the transition to the new quota share is “complete”.
The Brexit fisheries impact is discussed on The Pat Kenny Show here