Menu

Ireland's sailing, boating & maritime magazine

RBC Brewin Dolphin proudly supporting Afloat and Irish Boating

High Court Criticises EirGrid in Dublin Bay Fishing Dispute

22nd November 2026
Poolbeg Lighthouse at the entrance to Dublin Port, near the proposed Blackrock-to-Poolbeg electricity cable route involved in the EirGrid fishing dispute
Bay Dispute: Poolbeg Lighthouse at the entrance to Dublin Port, near the proposed electricity cable route across Dublin Bay between Blackrock and Poolbeg, where EirGrid's marine survey plans became the subject of High Court proceedings involving local fishermen. Credit: Afloat

State electricity grid operator EirGrid has been criticised by a High Court judge in a legal costs ruling arising from a dispute with fishermen over marine infrastructure survey work in Dublin Bay, according to a report by The Currency.

The proceedings concerned surveys for a proposed electricity cable across Dublin Bay as part of EirGrid's Powering Up Dublin programme. The State operator secured a maritime usage licence from the Maritime Area Regulatory Authority (MARA) to undertake the surveys and subsequently sought High Court injunctions in a dispute over fishing gear in the survey area.

Fisherman Seeks Costs Following Agreement

Greystones fisherman Ivan Toole, of Golden Venture Fishing Limited, became involved in the proceedings after identifying a potential impact on his fishing operations. EirGrid reached a separate agreement with him, but he pursued an application for his legal costs, arguing that he had been obliged to take legal action.

According to The Currency, Mr Justice David Holland criticised aspects of EirGrid's handling of the dispute when deciding the costs issue. The judge recognised the urgent public interest in the electricity project, while questioning whether EirGrid had met the responsibilities that accompanied that public interest.

The report says the judge considered that mediation and earlier engagement with those affected should have formed part of EirGrid's approach. He also distinguished between anyone deliberately placing fishing gear to obstruct work and fishermen exercising genuine fishing rights.

Survey Planning and Communication Questioned

The court was told, according to the report, that EirGrid had relied on a desktop assessment rather than checking fishing gear on the water. The judge also examined the timing of communications to fishermen about removing gear, against EirGrid's stated financial consequences of delay.

EirGrid has separately said that it engaged extensively with local stakeholders, including the fishing community, before the surveys. In its Powering Up Dublin project update, the company said objections to removing fishing gear led it to seek an urgent injunction, and that agreements were subsequently reached following mediation. EirGrid said delays would have significant consequences for the electricity infrastructure programme.

The dispute concerned access for survey work, rather than a court ruling that the proposed cable project or its maritime usage licence was unlawful.

Possible Appeal

The Currency reports that counsel for EirGrid sought and obtained a 28-day stay on the costs order because the company might appeal. The report does not establish that an appeal has been lodged.

The proposed cable is part of EirGrid's wider programme to strengthen electricity infrastructure in Dublin. EirGrid says the Carrickmines-to-Poolbeg connection includes approximately six kilometres across Dublin Bay, with marine surveys planned between spring 2026 and summer 2027.

Source: The Currency's report on the High Court costs ruling, with additional background from EirGrid's published project information.

Afloat.ie Team

About The Author

Afloat.ie Team

Email The Author

Afloat.ie is Ireland's dedicated marine journalism team.

Have you got a story for our reporters? Email us here.

We've got a favour to ask

More people are reading Afloat.ie than ever thanks to the power of the internet but we're in stormy seas because advertising revenues across the media are falling fast. Unlike many news sites, we haven't put up a paywall because we want to keep our marine journalism open.

Afloat.ie is Ireland's only full-time marine journalism team and it takes time, money and hard work to produce our content.

So you can see why we need to ask for your help.

If everyone chipped in, we can enhance our coverage and our future would be more secure. You can help us through a small donation. Thank you.

Direct Donation to Afloat button

Undersea Cables

Undersea cables are vital to Ireland's connectivity, facilitating high-speed internet, telecommunications, and energy transmission. These cables traverse the Irish Sea, connecting Ireland to the United Kingdom and continental Europe, and play a crucial role in global communications.

Submarine Communications Cables:
Ireland is strategically positioned along major transatlantic communication routes. Approximately 75% of transatlantic cables pass near Irish waters, underscoring the nation's significance in global data transmission.
These cables are typically as wide as a garden hose, with the filaments that carry light signals being extremely thin—roughly the diameter of a human hair. They are sheathed in layers of insulation and protection, with cables laid nearer to shore using extra layers of armoring for enhanced protection.

Energy Interconnectors:
In addition to communication cables, undersea interconnectors are being developed to enhance energy security and support the transition to renewable energy sources. The UK has approved the construction of five new subsea interconnector cables to boost the grid's flexibility amidst rising renewable energy. These projects will link the UK with wind farms in Belgium and the Netherlands, and connect England with Germany, Wales with Ireland, and Scotland with Northern Ireland. The cables, with a combined 6GW capacity, are expected to be operational by 2032, increasing the UK's total interconnector capacity to 18GW.

Security Concerns:
The strategic importance of these undersea cables has raised security concerns. Incidents in the Baltics have heightened awareness about the potential risks to subsea infrastructure. Ireland's historical neutrality and limited defense resources have led to calls for enhanced maritime security and defense investments, including modern surveillance technology and international cooperation. The government's response includes participation in EU security projects and collaboration with neighboring countries on maritime security.

In November 2024, a Russian spy ship, the Yantar, was escorted out of the Irish Sea by the Irish navy after it was found patrolling an area with critical submarine pipelines and cables. The vessel's presence heightened concerns due to its proximity to interconnector cables vital for internet services linking Ireland to the UK, operated by major tech companies such as Google and Microsoft.

Regulatory and Policy Framework:
The protection and maintenance of undersea cables fall under the jurisdiction of national governments, with private companies often responsible for their security. In Ireland, the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment oversees the regulation of telecommunications infrastructure, including undersea cables. The Irish Naval Service plays a role in monitoring and protecting maritime infrastructure, including undersea cables. Internationally, the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) provides a framework for the laying and maintenance of submarine cables, recognizing the "freedom of the seas" and the rights of coastal states.

Conclusion:
Undersea cables are indispensable to Ireland's connectivity and economic infrastructure. Given their strategic importance, ongoing efforts are necessary to ensure their protection and resilience against potential threats. This includes enhancing security measures, international cooperation, and adherence to regulatory frameworks to safeguard these critical assets.