State electricity grid operator EirGrid has been criticised by a High Court judge in a legal costs ruling arising from a dispute with fishermen over marine infrastructure survey work in Dublin Bay, according to a report by The Currency.
The proceedings concerned surveys for a proposed electricity cable across Dublin Bay as part of EirGrid's Powering Up Dublin programme. The State operator secured a maritime usage licence from the Maritime Area Regulatory Authority (MARA) to undertake the surveys and subsequently sought High Court injunctions in a dispute over fishing gear in the survey area.
Fisherman Seeks Costs Following Agreement
Greystones fisherman Ivan Toole, of Golden Venture Fishing Limited, became involved in the proceedings after identifying a potential impact on his fishing operations. EirGrid reached a separate agreement with him, but he pursued an application for his legal costs, arguing that he had been obliged to take legal action.
According to The Currency, Mr Justice David Holland criticised aspects of EirGrid's handling of the dispute when deciding the costs issue. The judge recognised the urgent public interest in the electricity project, while questioning whether EirGrid had met the responsibilities that accompanied that public interest.
The report says the judge considered that mediation and earlier engagement with those affected should have formed part of EirGrid's approach. He also distinguished between anyone deliberately placing fishing gear to obstruct work and fishermen exercising genuine fishing rights.
Survey Planning and Communication Questioned
The court was told, according to the report, that EirGrid had relied on a desktop assessment rather than checking fishing gear on the water. The judge also examined the timing of communications to fishermen about removing gear, against EirGrid's stated financial consequences of delay.
EirGrid has separately said that it engaged extensively with local stakeholders, including the fishing community, before the surveys. In its Powering Up Dublin project update, the company said objections to removing fishing gear led it to seek an urgent injunction, and that agreements were subsequently reached following mediation. EirGrid said delays would have significant consequences for the electricity infrastructure programme.
The dispute concerned access for survey work, rather than a court ruling that the proposed cable project or its maritime usage licence was unlawful.
Possible Appeal
The Currency reports that counsel for EirGrid sought and obtained a 28-day stay on the costs order because the company might appeal. The report does not establish that an appeal has been lodged.
The proposed cable is part of EirGrid's wider programme to strengthen electricity infrastructure in Dublin. EirGrid says the Carrickmines-to-Poolbeg connection includes approximately six kilometres across Dublin Bay, with marine surveys planned between spring 2026 and summer 2027.
Source: The Currency's report on the High Court costs ruling, with additional background from EirGrid's published project information.

















































