A group involving Irish New York-based hotelier John Fitzpatrick and retired Aran island GP Marion Broderick has called for re-opening of the tender for the Irish Coast Guard’s aviation service.
As The Sunday Independent reports, the group has written to Minister for Transport Darragh O’Brien, his junior minister Sean Canney and their department secretary-general Ken Spratt about the controversy.
Mr Fitzpatrick, New York hotelier, is said to have an interest in aviation, while Dr Broderick has been a long-time medical officer for the RNLI lifeboat on the Aran islands. Independent senator Gerard Craughwell and Sligo county councillor Dónal Gilroy also signed the letter.
It expresses concerns about a “rushed transition” to a new operator, and the use of a helicopter which is “too small…for this critical service”.
The group lists what they claim to be a number of breaches of contract by the current operator, Bristow Ireland, which “warrant the re-opening of the tender entirely with adequate oversight and governance”.
They describe the current situation with the contract as a “metaphorical volcano which is about to erupt”.
The three-page letter lists a number of questions about the ten-year 816 million euro (VAT included) contract signed between the Department of Transport and Bristow Ireland Ltd on August 22nd, 2023.
These include whether the successful applicant was approximately 60 million euro dearer than its nearest rival, CHC Ireland, and whether two of three assessors engaged by the department to review the applications had previously been employed by the Bristow group “or its subsidiaries either in this or other jurisdictions”.
They question the rationale for approving the Leonardo AW189 helicopter, in spite of it having less carrying capacity than the Sikorsky S-92 flown by outgoing operator CHC Ireland.
They also ask if there is recourse in light of an “extremely problematic” and delayed transition to the new operator at all four bases with “capability and safety concerns being raised” by medical professionals, the public and “helicopter crews”.
The group lists a number of Irish Aviation Authority (IAA) approvals which warranted a “significant percentage of marks” in the bidding process, but which Bristow Ireland did not have in place at the time of the contract award and “several of which remain outstanding”.
The Department of Transport said that the new contract “will greatly enhance the capacity and capability of the Irish Coast Guard to help save more lives and to protect the environment long into the future”.
“At this time, the department is prioritising the safe phased transition of the new service, and we welcome the ongoing support we are receiving from a wide range of stakeholders and communities who rely on this essential state service,”it said.
Bristow Ireland did not provide a comment.
Read The Sunday Independent here

















































