Politicians on the Oireachtas transport committee members expressed “shock” yesterday at a claim that Irish Coast Guard search and rescue (SAR) helicopter crews had been threatened with disciplinary action if they logged 24-hour shifts as working for 24 hours.
As The Irish Independent reports, the claim was made by Fórsa trade union representatives at the committee’s hearing into working time hours for SAR air crews.
The issue for discussion was a “factoring” system operated by Bristow Ireland, holder of the contract for the Irish Coast Guard, which means that 24 hour shifts are only logged as 16.5 hours.
Fórsa trade union assistant general secretary Eugene Gargan said that Bristow had informed it that “should any of our members refuse to work more than 2,000 clock hours [the legal limit], they would be immediately subject to the full rigours of their disciplinary process”.
Sinn Féin TD Conor McGuinness and Labour Party senator Nessa Cosgrove expressed their shock at the threat of disciplinary action, especially in light of the invaluable role played by SAR crews in saving lives.
The committee, chaired by Fine Gael TD Michael Murphy, was told by Bristow Ireland representatives that the company is compliant with all legislation in operating this practice and said it has been approved by the Irish Aviation Authority (IAA) as State regulator.
Bristow director Philip Bartlett explained that the staff working on 24-hour shifts are on “standby” between the hours of 10 pm and 8 am.
However, trade unions Fórsa and the Irish Airline Pilots Association (IALPA) maintain that the crews are not on standby but are fully working as they have to remain on base, and have to be in a state of “immediate readiness” for a call-out.
Mr McGuinness said that he believed if the “factoring” system was tested in the courts, both in Europe and nationally, Bristow Ireland, the IAA and the Government would “be found wanting”.
Bristow Ireland director James Lorraine said the company “does not lobby” when asked by Mr McGuinness if it had lobbied the IAA on interpretation of the existing regulations.
However, Mr Lorraine confirmed that there had been contact between the two legal teams representing Bristow and the IAA “to verify compliance”.
He also confirmed that there would be a “cost impact” to the company if factoring was removed.
IALPA vice-president Capt Daniel Langan said his union believes that a fatigue risk management system (FRMS) brought in after the Rescue 116 crash off north Mayo was being “misused” by the IAA to justify the operation of factoring.
Capt Mark O’Callaghan of IALPA said the EU working time directive needs to be fully recognised to resolve the issue.
Derek Everitt of the search and rescue technical crew, who has 28 years SAR experience, explained the detailed background to the crews’ opposition to “factoring”.
Everitt said that it was the only State emergency service operating 24-hour shifts.
The Oireachtas transport committee plans to write to Bristow and to the IAA to seek copies of the legal advice relating to the decision, on foot of a motion proposed by Fianna Fáil TD Cathal Crowe and seconded by Mr McGuinness (SF).
The IAA is expected to appear before the committee in early January, and the Minister for Transport will appear before the end of that month, according to the chairman.
Read The Irish Independent here

















































