The Irish Whale and Dolphin Group’s (IWDG) call for a moratorium on all sprat fishing has been opposed by a leading fisheries body representing the industry in Ireland’s South West.
As previously reported on Afloat.ie, the IWDG has urged Minister of State for Fisheries Timmy Dooley to “be bold” and “ambitious” regarding his options over the inshore fishery for sprat and other forage fish.
Numbers of such fish species have reportedly declined in West Cork, forcing the closure of at least one whale watching business as larger whales have moved north following their preferred prey.
“Without a detailed understanding of the stock, precautionary advice by the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES) recommends an annual catch of sprat not exceeding 2,240 tonnes,” the IWDG says.
“However landings for the past few years have been many times that figure. A moratorium should be considered to enable the Marine Institute to collect and process the appropriate data to support a sustainable quota.”
Irish South & West Fish Producers’ Organisation chief executive Patrick Murphy, however, argues that the IWDG’s cited figures do not tell the whole story.
“When advice is provided by ICES it is governed by the data it has available to it,” he tells Afloat.ie. “Sprat would be acknowledged as a data-deficient stock but it has recorded landings that are not only steady but increasing.
“So why is the IWDG asking for a moratorium? Do they not want our fishermen earn a living?”
Murphy, who claims the IWDG has so far “refused to sit down with us in industry”, has suggested that a third party could act or mediate “to see if we together can seek proper science to make an informed management plan for this important species that has a life span of just three to five years”.

















































