Minister of State for Fisheries Timmy Dooley has asked his Cabinet colleague Minister for Transport Darragh O’Brien to take up issues relating to the former fishing vessel Mary Kate.
In a letter to owner CJ Gaffney of Arklow, Mr Dooley says that the referral follows his commitment to progress contact with the German ministry and with the European Commission’s directorate general for mobility and transport (DGMOVE).
He believes that “questions which arose regarding the integrity of the safety certification process undertaken by the German authorities in respect of this particular vessel” are more appropriate for Mr O’Brien’s department to pursue.
As reported by Afloat, Mr Gaffney tried to take legal action in both the Netherlands and Germany after he discovered stability issues with the vessel, Mary Kate. He took out a loan to cover fixing the vessel and then had to surrender it to the bank in 2012.
He sought EU funds in compensation, but the EU said it was up to the national state, and indicated the Irish government could make a special case.
The vessel was broken up in New Ross, Co Wexford under the Irish government’s decommissioning scheme.
Gaffney maintains that questions need to be asked at both national level and EU level as to how the beam trawler was issued with a stamped stability book from a renowned international classification society.
Gaffney also says questions should also be asked as to how a valid ship sailing permit was issued when it had 20 tonnes of unaccounted steel present since new build, and how the case was handled after various authorities had been notified of this.
“If this is not sorted, this is a life sentence,” he told an Oireachtas committee some months ago.
Stability expert Justin Delaney, who appeared with Mr Gaffney before the committee, said that 11 sister vessels were built, and three of them are similar to the Mary Kate – as in four “incorrect vessels” which were much heavier in the water.
He told the committee how he had tried to raise the issue with German ministers and the Dutch safety board.
“These vessels were given stability booklets and information that was not correct…it was only when CJ began to operate the Mary Kate …that true stability deficiencies became apparent,”Mr Delaney said.
“I am totally shocked an official EU investigation has not happened – beam trawlers are the most dangerous type of fishing,” Mr Delaney said.
He described it as a “huge case in terms of maritime safety” which should have been resolved back in 2010.
Mr Dooley has said in his letter to Mr Gaffney that any approaches made by him to the German ministry or DG MOVE” would be outside the remit of my department”.
“That being the case I have been in contact directly with my colleague, Darragh O'Brien, Minister for Transport, to highlight the issues raised at our meeting,”he has said.
“ In particular I have asked Minister O'Brien if he could raise concerns regarding the integrity of the certification process undertaken by the German authorities in respect of this particular vessel with both the relevant German ministry and with DGMOVE”.
“I can confirm that officials from my department will continue to engage with officials from the Department of Transport with regards to issues arising from your case,”he said..
“I remain available and willing to work with Minister O'Brien to address these matters, recognising that safety certification of vessels is outside the remit of this department,”Mr Dooley concluded.

















































