A Welsh government agency study of marine protected areas (MPAs) within its waters has found that no assessed habitat or species has been negatively impacted by fishing.
The Natural Resources Wales study was released at a time when there is growing international pressure by environmental NGOs to ban all bottom trawling in MPAs – influenced by David Attenborough’s film, Ocean.
England’s Marine Management Organisation (MMO) has sparked alarm among fishermen over its proposal to ban bottom trawling in most of England’s offshore MPAs.
French fishermen have called for the 12-week consultation period initiated by the MMO to be extended from September 1st to November 1st.
As of May 2024, Britain has designated 377 MPAs, covering 38% of UK waters in total. Each devolved government has its own designation system and management powers.
Wales has 139 protected sites, covering 69% of the inshore area and 50% of all Welsh waters.
The study by Natural Resources Wales analysed the condition of 84 features of MPAs within Welsh waters.
.Welsh fisheries minister Huw Irranca-Davies said the findings of the study were “critically important” in relation to considering any further restrictions on bottom-towed gear within the Welsh MPA network.
.“We will take a proportionate, balanced, consistent, evidence-led approach, as we have done before, when considering the need for any potential management measures; in particular, how such measures may impact as well the livelihoods of the fishing sector and the coastal communities that they support,” he told the Welsh government or Senned.
Speaking about the MMO consultation on proposals to ban bottom gear in some of the 42 MPAs in English waters, Irranca-Davies said he had “no plans to follow an identical course of action in Wales, because the evidence here does not identify such a need”.
“Consideration by the Welsh Government of any potential restrictions on the use of bottom-towed gears within Welsh MPAs will be based on the most robust evidence, the needs of the features and the site conservation objectives,” he said.
EU Commissioner for Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Costas Kadis attracted criticism from environmental NGOs when he said he believed any restrictive activities relating to fishing in MPAs should be approached on a “case by case” basis.
Sweden has decided to introduce a general ban on bottom trawling in MPAs from July 1st, 2026, while Denmark has bans covering some 30 per cent of its waters, mainly to the south and east.

















































