A group of Irish fishing vessel owners have initiated a legal challenge to the Government’s ban on trawling inside six-nautical miles.
As The Skipper reports, a legal team for over 20 vessel owners lodged an application in the High Court on December 18th last, and the first hearing is expected in February 2026.
This is the second time fishing vessel owners have challenged such a restriction, which was first attempted in 2018 by the Government, and quashed by a court of appeal decision in 2021.
The trawling ban for vessels over 18 metres in length inside six nautical miles and baselines does not come into force in full until October 1st, 2026.
It is supported by inshore vessels attached to the National Inshore Fishermen’s Association and environmental groups.
However, larger vessel owners from both sides of the border argue they have lost 50 per cent of their potential income this year as a result of the recent EU fisheries council decision on total allowable catches and quotas.
The impact of scientific advice and resulting reductions in quota, combined with the blocking of the Hague Preferences, has cut an estimated one third of Ireland's fish quota for 2026, at an estimated direct lost of €100-€105m, based on 2025 quota values.
Irish seafood organisations say that 2,300 jobs are at risk, and the cuts were compounded by the actions of four member states - France, Netherlands, Germany and Poland - which blocked invocation of the Hague Preferences, a long-standing protection mechanism for Ireland which secured a larger share of certain stocks when total allowable catches fall below a specific level.
The judicial review seeks to overturn policy directive 1 of 2025, signed by Minister for Agriculture, Food and Marine Martin Heydon and Minister of State for Fishermen Timmy Dooley in September 2025.
Irish South and West Fish Producers’ Organisation chief executive Patrick Murphy told The Skipper magazine that it was “regrettable” that the legal action was “once again necessary”.
He said vessel owners could not afford to “lose access to historical fishing opportunities based on an ill-informed Programme for Government decision that discriminates based solely on vessel size and not on any current verifiable scientific and socio- economic advice”.
Murphy has long maintained that a full scientific and economic assessment must take place before any restriction can be considered.
The Department of Agriculture, Food and Marine did initiate a public consultation on a revised attempt to ban trawling inside the six nautical mile zone and baselines in 2024.
It suggested four options – no change; exclusion of pair trawling vessels inside six miles; exclusion of all sea fishing vessels over 18m length trawling inside six miles; and all sea fishing boats over 15m in length excluded from trawling inside six miles.
Environmental organisations, which sought a complete ban inside six nautical miles, are concerned about the impact on marine life and risk of bycatch of marine mammals.
The new ban is not due to come into effect until October 1st, 2026, when trawling activity by fishing vessels over 18 metres in length overall inside the six nautical mile zone and the baselines will be prohibited.
The announcement by the two ministers also stated that a catch limit of 2,000 tonnes of sprat would be permitted for vessels over 18 metres length overall inside the six nautical mile zone and inside baselines from October 1st 2025 to September 30th, 2026 only.
The ministers said that as the introduction of the new measures may affect vessels that are owned and operated in Northern Ireland, the start date for the application of the catch limit has been amended to October 11th to allow a sufficient notification period for Britain under Article 496(3) of the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement.

















































