The Oireachtas Public Accounts Committee has agreed to raise a number of issues relating to the State’s search and rescue (SAR) contract with the Department of Transport.
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) secretariat was responding to concerns raised about the 800 million euro ten-year contract by a group involving Irish New York-based hotelier John Fitzpatrick and retired Aran island GP Marion Broderick.
Late last week (Thursday 21st August) Minister of State of Transport Sean Canney officially introduced the Coast Guard’s new aviation fleet at Shannon airport under contract to Bristow Ireland, describing it as “a crucial milestone for Ireland’s maritime safety and environmental protection”.
Several months ago (May 2025), the group of four signatories, including Fitzpatrick and Broderick, Independent senator Gerard Craughwell and Sligo county councillor Dónal Gilroy, called on the Minister for Transport to reopen the tender for the SAR helicopter service.
In a letter to Minister for Transport Darragh O’Brien, junior minister Sean Canney and their department secretary-general Ken Spratt, the group referred to a “rushed transition” to a new operator, and the use of a helicopter which is “too small…for this critical service”.
The group listed what they claim to be a number of breaches of contract by the current operator, Bristow Ireland, which “warrant the re-opening of the tender entirely with adequate oversight and governance”.
They described the current situation with the contract as a “metaphorical volcano which is about to erupt”.
Their three-page letter listed a number of questions about the ten-year 816 million euro (VAT included) contract signed between the Department of Transport and Bristow Ireland Ltd on August 22nd, 2023.
These included whether the successful applicant was approximately 60 million euro dearer than its nearest rival, CHC Ireland, and whether two of three assessors engaged by the department to review the applications had previously been employed by the Bristow group “or its subsidiaries either in this or other jurisdictions”.
They questioned the rationale for approving the Leonardo AW189 helicopter, in spite of it having less carrying capacity than the Sikorsky S-92 flown by outgoing operator CHC Ireland.
The group listed a number of Irish Aviation Authority (IAA) approvals which warranted a “significant percentage of marks” in the bidding process, but which Bristow Ireland did not have in place at the time of the contract award and “several of which remain outstanding”.
Earlier this year, the IAA recently banned Bristow Ireland from transporting patients on its stretchers until further notice as the initial system they had in the new helicopters was not compliant with safety and regulatory standards.
Defending the contract, the Department of Transport has said that it“will greatly enhance the capacity and capability of the Irish Coast Guard to help save more lives and to protect the environment long into the future”. Bristow Ireland said it would not comment as it had not seen the letter.
The PAC secretariat has told the concerned group’s representative, Sean Perry, that its correspondence was “brought to the attention of and considered by the committee at a private meeting in June 2025”.
“The Committee have agreed to write to the Department of Transport and have requested details on a number of matters in relation to the search and rescue contract,”it said, adding that it “will consider the matter further upon receipt of the response”.
A 24-hour fixed-wing service with two Beechcraft B200 King Air aircraft is based at Shannon Airport as part of the new contract Photo: Liam Burke/Press 22
Bristow began using the new fleet of AW189 helicopters from Shannon in December, and it took over the Dublin-based service in July. It is operating from Weston Airport - closing a 27-year-old Coast Guard search and rescue base at Dublin Airport.
The other two bases in Waterford and Sligo are still being run by outgoing operator CHC Ireland under an extended contract, due to delays in Bristow’s transition.
A 24-hour fixed wing service with two Beechcraft B200 King Air aircraft will be based at Shannon as part of the new contract. The fixed wing element is due to transfer to the Air Corps halfway through the ten-year term.

















































